Adventist Online

I was listening to the sermon last Sabbath and the pastor was mentioning Sister White and used Rev 12:17 and 19:10 to prove that she was the Spirit of Prophecy, and since she is, then therefore our church is the remnant church. I don't disagree that we have the remnant message, or that Mrs. White had prophetic visions, but what hit me when I read these verses is this,: the spirit of prophecy, the very heart of prophecy, the focus and destination and ultimate purpose of prophecy, not the letter of- but the spirit of, is the testimony of Jesus, the written Word and spoken Word about the Living Word. Does anyone understand this concept? So why do we call sister white the SOP?

Views: 1308

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Ellen White is called the SOP to lessen the emphasis on Her as the only prophetic voice. The 18 fundamental belief outlines the Spirit of Prophecy as one of the gifts of the Spirit and the identifying mark of the Remnant Church. Thus, the prophetic ministry of Ellen White is proof that the SDA church is the remnant church. It also indicates that her writings are a continuing and authoritative source of truth. In reading this belief one would be led to believe that Ellen White is the only source for the SOP.

I would say that most SDA's believe in some variation of this belief, I am on of the minority who do not hold to this belief. I don't see any indication in the word of God that one messenger is going to take on that type of importance, and holding to only Ellen White, diminishes insight from other sources. The spirit of prophecy or prophesying is reflecting the ministry of the Gospel (Christ) to the world. The bible indicates that this is a collective ministry (Joel 2:28 Corinthians 14:1-12, ) and should be desired by all Christians. Limiting the SOP to one person and to one message is a serious error. I have seen this turn into outright worship of Ellen White, in which her work is seen as infallible, and her message is placed ahead of the Bible.

As far the SOP being the proof of the remnant Church, I am very skeptical that this true or even healthy for our church. First the moniker of the "one true church," was first coined by the Catholic church, message that became oppressive very quickly. Thinking that you are the only faith with the truth produces an exclusive rather than an inclusive ministry. Instead of teaching Christ and increasing faith, you tend to preach salvation comes through us (our organization.) Since the SDA Church is not specifically listed in the scripture as the "one true church," and history has proven that this distinction can be unhealthy, and even dangerous, I cannot see that it is a good thing. 

Thanks for letting me share, what are your feelings.


One of the gifts of the Holy Spirit is prophecy. This gift is an identifying mark of the remnant church and was manifested in
the ministry of Ellen. G. White. As the Lord’s messenger, her writings are a continuing and authoritative source of truth which
provide for the church comfort, guidance, instruction, and correction. They also make clear that the Bible is the standard by

Herbert: Excellent analysis and honest conclusion, not being blinded by groupthink. 

I agree with you completely, you have hit the nail on the head. I left a ministry that had similar attitudes as well as other serious issues. These attitudes and beliefs as you have well defined and their dangers lead to exclusion and not inclusion, denial of the one body of Christ which is composed of believers from many different groups, or even individuals not organized into denominational organizations, but are spiritually organized as Jesus has determined as part of the body of Christ who works with others if possible.

It is not healthy indeed. Instead of allowing for differences and a general principle of continual searching for the truth, or redefining what we believe to be the truth, people's minds are made up and closed to further truth or re-understanding by research. The limitation of all beliefs, books, socializing, marriage, teachings, contacts, friendships to the organization while looking down and in some cases by some people dispising other believers, and thinking they are totally evil etc. is unchristian-like.

Defining EGW as the "Spirit of Prophesy" denies the scriptures and the holy spirit and its operation on this subject, as the only fountainhead of truth and prophesy. Others need not apply, though this same denomination (though not alone in this in Christianity) deny all or many or most others of being inspired or operating with the holy spirit and in Christ's approval. The holding to we are the only and genuine remnant while failing to have contemporary operations of holy spirit as stipulated in the scriptures as well as by the true spirit of God that encourages walking by the spirit in love and power, which is denied and even attacked without understanding or evidence as demonic often in a knee-jerk cognitive-dissonance and hateful manner. 

My own experience here and how some have treated me, as well as others including you Mr. Bryan is a testimony to the unchristian and unhealthy beliefs and attitudes and even behavior the above causes in some members of this site and SDA members, though all do not share these "attitudes." But it is prevalent enough as it is.

Some in the SDA have a cult-like closed society circle the wagons they are all the enemy attitude and lifestyle.

We need to hold to the truth, but be willing to learn and grow and expand on areas of research, double checking things taken for granted. But there are some here and in the SDA church who are open-minded in the good sense.

When I was in the former group I was in, I didn't like to be called or compared to cults, but there was truth to it to some extent, and when I found out of both the corruption of the leadership in abusing women and other grievances and practices, I and many thousands left the organization. It was difficult emotionally, and many friends and family members separated at that time. Similar things I understand occur with SDA and other denominations.

One important thing which you Herbert touched on; that EGW is the only source of prophecy. There has been no prophesying in over 100 years since her death! But that does not mean there is no prophesy in the body of Christ or other operations of the holy spirit. To paint everyone that speaks in tongues or does other manifestations of holy spirit automatically as evil, of the Devil and of the Kundalini spirit is evil, without evidence, experience or true understanding of the holy spirit field. The SDA does not have a corner on the market for the holy spirit, and in fact, does not manifest by practice and doctrine almost any manifestations of holy spirit (referring to the 9 manifestations).

I have recognized a few rare cases of revelation and told the people that did so or asked about it that it was revelation from the Lord. But there are exceedingly rare, and even hearing the still small voice which is revealed is determined by Pastor T previously and some others as being categorized and falsely judged as "mental illness." Elijah and JasonM's practice in that methodology has been experienced by myself. Anyone who operates any or all nine manifestations is not better or greater than other believers, but rather has a greater responsibility and difficult hardship in this unbelieving in the holy spirit environment. We are all sinners. There is also great lack of confidence not only in the holy spirit operations, but even in individual's salvation, despite New Testament scriptures to the contrary. This is also most unfortunate, and these both cause great harm, hurt and loss of opportunity for relief, peace, confidence, healing, and deliverance.

The only prophet that many if not most SDA recognize in modern times is EGW, despite the fact and truth that there is almost no manifestations (erroneously called "gifts.") in the SDA as well as the majority of Christianity, and yet these people who have no experience, accurate knowledge or practice, or guidance by revelation propose to be judge of others as to the real and genuine spirit of God while defaming others as demonic. Just like playing golf, those that have never played golf, do not understand the rules, have no desire to do so, stand judging others swinging the ball and occasionally even getting a hole in one spiritually speaking, while occasionally also missing a shot here and there.

We prophesy in part and know in part, yet most never have or will prophesy. In fact other than EGW, who has ever prophesied in the SDA in the last 100 years? The absence of the spirit in operation speaks volumes not only to the SDA, but also the body of Christ in general if only they would "listen" to the silence and realize it is not a good sign. That being said, even speaking in tongues is a sign, as Jesus and Paul said. Yes, there are counterfeits of everything. But genuine manifestations are supposed to be in operation until Jesus Christ returns. In that most of Christianity is in unbelief and apostasy to some extent as well as other problems too numerous to state here.

There are many kind and loving and reasonable people here at Adventist Online, but there is also the spirit of pride in thinking that they are a part of the unique and only remnant, and have the spirit of prophesy, though no one does prophesy? That is ironic. There is no tradition of operating any manifestations of the holy spirit other than holding to every word, action, belief and attitude of EGW as a prophet, and as the only prophet since Bible days.

It is most unfortunate that the spirit of God is not tapped into, after all, it is in each and every genuine believer in Christ. Silence in the SDA of the spirit is the norm, and any manifestation of the holy spirit, even if genuine is looked down upon as completely evil, without evidence, witnesses, understanding, experience or revelation in this area.

Jesus Christ is waiting for those who will actually believe what the scriptures say about the spirit of God and its manifestations, and act in accordance with the scriptures and the spirit. He and his Father have been waiting a long time, and continue to do so. Many may find that their pride and arrogance as some practice here in unbelief of the spirit of God, that their attitudes and unbelief is not pleasing to God and will not be rewarded as such. These are not easy things to contemplate, and I hope and wish they were not so?

18. The Gift of Prophecy:
One of the gifts of the Holy Spirit is prophecy. This gift is an identifying mark of the remnant church and was manifested in the ministry of Ellen. G. White . As the Lord's messenger, her writings are a continuing and authoritative source of truth which provide for the church comfort, guidance, instruction, and correction. They also make clear that the Bible is the standard by which all teaching and experience must be tested. (Joel 2:28, 29; Acts 2:14-21; Heb. 1:1-3; Rev. 12:17; 19:10.)

The Prophetic Gift in the Last Days
Many Christians believe that the gift of prophecy ceased at the close of the apostolic era. But the Bible reveals the church's special need for divine guidance during the crisis at the time of the end; it testifies to a continuing need for and provision of the prophetic gift after New Testament times.

Continuation of Spiritual Gifts. There is no Biblical evidence that God would withdraw the spiritual gifts He gave the church before they had completed their purpose, which, according to Paul, was to bring the church "to the unity of the faith and the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ" (Eph. 4:13). Because the church has not yet reached this experience, it still needs all the gifts of the Spirit. These gifts, including the gift of prophecy, will continue to operate for the benefit of God's people until Christ returns. Consequently, Paul cautioned believers not to "quench the Spirit" or "despise prophecies" (1 Thess. 5:19, 20) and counseled, "Desire spiritual gifts, but especially that you may prophesy" (1 Cor. 14:1).

These gifts have not always manifested themselves abundantly in the Christian church.5 After the death of the apostles, prophets enjoyed respectability in many circles until A.D. 300.6 But the decline of spirituality in the church and the resultant apostasy (see chapter 12 of this book), led to a diminishing of both the presence and the gifts of the Holy Spirit. At the same time false prophets caused a loss of confidence in the prophetic gift. 7

The decline of the prophetic gift during certain periods in church history did not mean that God had withdrawn the gift permanently. The Bible indicates that, as the end approaches, this gift will be present to assist the church through those difficult times. More than that, it points to an increased activity of this gift.

The Prophetic Gift in the Remnant Church. Revelation 12 reveals two major periods of persecution. During the first, which extended from A.D. 538 to A.D. 1798 (Rev. 12:6, 14; see chapter 12 of this book), loyal believers suffered intense persecution. Again, just before the Second Advent, Satan will attack "the remnant of her offspring," the remnant church that refuses to give up allegiance to Christ. Revelation characterizes the loyal believers who make up the remnant as they "who keep the commandments of God and have the testimony of Jesus Christ" (Rev. 12:17).

That the phrase "the testimony of Jesus" speaks of prophetic revelation is clear from later conversations between the angel and John.8

Near the end of the book the angel identifies himself as "'your fellow servant, and of your brethren who have the testimony of Jesus'" (Rev. 19:10) and "'your fellowservant, and of your brethren the prophets'" (Rev. 22:9). These parallel expressions make it clear that it is the prophets who have "the testimony of Jesus."9 This explains the angel's statement that "'the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy'" (Rev. 19:10).

Commenting on this text, James Moffat wrote, "'For the testimony or witness of (i.e., borne by) Jesus is (i.e., constitutes) the spirit of prophecy.' This. . . specially defines the brethren who hold the testimony of Jesus as possessors of prophetic inspiration. The testimony of Jesus is practically equivalent to Jesus testifying (xxii.20). It is the self-revelation of Jesus (according to [Rev.] 1:1, due ultimately to God) which moves the Christian prophets."10

So the expression the Spirit of prophecy can refer to (1) the Holy Spirit's inspiring the prophet with a revelation from God, (2) the operation of the gift of prophecy, and (3) the medium of prophecy itself.

The prophetic gift, Jesus' witness "to the church through the medium of prophecy, "11 comprises a distinctive characteristic of the remnant church. Jeremiah linked the demise of this gift with lawlessness. "The Law is no more, and her prophets find no vision from the Lord" (Lam. 2:9). Revelation identifies the possession of the two as distinctive characteristics of the end-time church; its members "keep the commandments of God and have the testimony of Jesus Christ"—the prophetic gift (Rev. 12:17). God gave the prophetic gift to the "church" of the Exodus to organize, instruct, and guide His people (Acts 7:38, KJV). "By a prophet the Lord brought Israel out of Egypt, and by a prophet he was preserved" (Hosea 12:13). It comes as no surprise, then, to find that gift among those who are involved in the ultimate exodus—the escape from sin-polluted Planet Earth to the heavenly Canaan. This exodus, which will follow the Second Advent, is the final and complete fulfillment of Isaiah 11:11: "It shall come to pass in that day that the Lord shall set His hand again the second time to recover the remnant of His people who are left."

Help in the Final Crisis. The Scriptures reveal that God's people in the last days of earth's history will experience the full wrath of the satanic dragon power as he engages in a final attempt to destroy them (Rev. 12:17). This will "be a time of trouble, such as never was since there was a nation" (Dan. 12:1). To help them survive this most intense conflict of the ages, God in His loving-kindness gave His people the assurance that they would not be alone. The testimony of Jesus, the Spirit of prophecy, would guide them safely to their final objective—unification with their Saviour at the Second Advent.

The following illustration explains the relationship between the Bible and post-Biblical instances of the prophetic gift: "Suppose we are about to start upon a voyage. The owner of the vessel gives us a book of directions, telling us that it contains instructions sufficient for our whole journey, and that if we will heed them, we shall reach in safety our port of destination. Setting sail, we open our book to learn its contents. We find that its author lays down general principles to govern us in our voyage, and instructs us as far as practicable, judging the various contingencies that may arise till the end; but he also tells us that the latter part of our journey will be especially perilous; that the features of the coast are ever changing by reason of quicksands and tempests; 'but for this part of the journey,' says he, 'I have provided you a pilot, who will meet you, and give you such directions as the surrounding circumstances and dangers may require; and to him you must give heed.' With these directions we reach the perilous times specified, and the pilot, according to promise, appears. But some of the crew, as he offers his services, rise up against him. 'We have the original book of directions,' say they, 'and that is enough for us. We stand upon that, and that alone; we want nothing of you.' Who now heeds that original book of directions? those who reject the pilot, or those who receive him, as that book instructs them? Judge ye."12

 Brother Ian,great illustration, I've heard it at least 3 times from the pulpit. In your statement you ascertain that because the angel  identifies himself first as John's fellow servant and with John's brethren who have the testimony of Christ, then as John's fellow servant and with John's brethren the prophets, this is proof that the testimony of Christ actually means the Spirit of Prophecy.

Allow me to put forth another possibility. Could it be that the angel is identifying himself as a fellow servant with Spiritual Israelites, which includes gentiles (those that have the testimony of Christ) and as a fellow servant with the original Israelites, which was had only a few gentile proselytes that were very limited (your brethren the prophets?)   

Could it be, as I stated in the introduction, that the Spirit- Pneuma= breath, source , vital principal, life giving power, governing influence, driving force- of Prophecy is actually the Testimony Of Christ? In fact, that's the way the Bible records the phrases together. Not the other way around, which seems to be the position of many of our brethren?

Elijah quotes scriptures about the truth that the Holy Spirit is available as in the first century, but in practice opposes speaking in tongues, prophesy and other manifestations by blanket denouncement as evil and painting the person as Kundalini spirit. Yes, there are false prophets, but where is the genuine spirit of God in operation?

The lack of use and understanding of the spirit of God in manifestation throughout most of history since Acts 2 is a very sad commentary on unbelief. That bright glorious period in Acts and the early church stand as a great testimony and example of how the body of Christ should be operating and functioning.

i feel like one crying in the wilderness, no one listens to me or more importantly to God’s still small voice, and dare walk in power and love of God and manifest God’s desire to speak, heal, deliver, bless, edify, guide etc.

I do not speak without understanding or experience in these spiritual matters. But my ego is not important, it is the truth that is important.

A great man of God Smith Wigglesworth who lived in the late 19th century to the first half of the 20th century preached and worked mighty miracles including 14 documented cases of raising people from the dead. He believed God literally and spoke in tongues much, 2 hours a day which was one of the reasons he was so successful in walking by the spirit in power and love.

Smith Wigglesworth or any believer since the Day of Pentecost has the exact same measure of Holy Spirit, and has the whole power of God in manifestation waiting to be utilized as the Lord directs. This is part of the lost truths given to Paul and the body of Christ, called the sacred secrets to which I have devoted many decades in learning about as well as how the Holy Spirit works to some degree. Despite some amazing things I have seen God do, I have only scratched the surface. So I speak the truth, I am not special or specially anointed etc. I just to some extent have believed God at his word and stepped out in faith.

Who has the faith, desire and love to do the wonderful works of God? To speak for God in the spirit. Is there one among you? 

Look to yourselves and your faith before you blatantly judge others, oh ye of little faith. The majority of you are born again and therefore have all things as promised, whether you know, understand or believe it. Seek and ye shall find, knock and the door shall be opened unto you.

Explain to me how God blesses a person who is knowingly breaking God's law? You are a liar and you know about the Sabbath that you reject out of hand. You do not show any fruits of the Spirit, but plenty of fruits of the flesh. As far as I know, the Bible condemns such a person.  

Ellen White is dead, how can she be the spirit of prophecy? The SOP ie not a human being ....

Well well JasonM, for once I agree with you. All ministries end (other than Jesus Christ's) at the death of the person.

People may be inspired by, follow, read about etc. certain ministries, some of which are in the Bible. But these are supposed to be examples for others to follow.

Glad you asked, Charlie B. Maybe this might help answer your question.


This was insightful found these paragraphs particularly interesting;

No matter how long we have been saying it, Sister White’s writings are not what Revelation 19:10 refers to as “the spirit of prophecy.” Like all other divine messages brought to us by human instrumentality, they may have been inspired by that spirit. There certainly is ample evidence that they indeed are, as Uriah Smith declared them, a manifestation of that spirit. But our practice of assigning to them that title or others like it is excessive to say the least. It’s a wonder we haven’t added titles like Her Holiness to the mix.

Our boast of having it all and needing no further light is so unmistakably Laodicean. It is this very delusion that the Lord finds so nauseating he warns he will have to spew us out of his mouth: “Because thou sayest, I am rich, and increased with goods, and have need of nothing; and knowest not that thou art wretched, and miserable, and poor, and blind, and naked” (Revelation 3:17).


So, how was Mass today?  I noticed you were gone pretty much all day, I spent the day laying cement.


You did? Working on the venerable day of the sun? 

 The earliest recognition of the observance of Sunday as a legal duty is a constitution of Constantine in A.D. 321, enacting that all courts of justice, inhabitants of towns, and workshops were to be at rest on Sunday (venerabili die Solis), with an exception in favour of those engaged in agricultural labour...The Council of Laodicea (363) ... forbids Christians from judaizing and resting on the Sabbath day, preferring the Lord's day, and so far as possible resting as Christians."-Encyclopaedia Britannica, 1899 Edition, Vol. XXIII, page 654


Site Sponsors


Adventist Single?
Meet other Single
Adventists here:
Join Free

USA members:

Support AO by
using this link:


© 2018   Created by Clark P.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service